Talha ibn Sa'id

٤٢٨٣- Talha ibn Sa'id «٣» :

ibn Amr ibn Murra al-Juhani.

Ibn al-Kalbi said: he had companionship (with the Prophet), and Ibn al-Athir included him as an additional entry.

I say: I have not seen any mention of his father Sa'id among the Companions, so it is possible that he died young, while his grandfather Amr is a well-known Companion.

٤٢٨٤ z- Talha ibn Abd Allah al-Laythi «٤» :

Ibn Hibban mentioned him in "the Companions", and said: it is said that he had companionship. And al-Duri said, on the authority of Ibn Ma'in:

Talha ibn Abd Allah al-Nadri: they say he had companionship. Ibn Shahin and Ibn al-Sakan reported it, and likewise Ibn Sa'd said. And he added: he is of Banu Layth.

And Abu Ahmad al-Askari said: Talha ibn Malik al-Laythi, and it is also said Talha ibn Abd Allah.

I say: Ibn al-Athir, following others, confused this entry with the entry of Talha ibn Amr al-Nadri, which comes shortly, and I think that is the correct one.

---

(١) Usd al-Ghaba, entry ٢٦٢٣; al-Isti'ab, entry ١٢٨٦. And al-Isti'ab.
(٢) In (the manuscript) Awbayn al-Arqam Abi al-Arqam.
(٣) Usd al-Ghaba, entry ٢٦٢٥.
(٤) Tarikh Khalifa ٢٦٨; Tabaqat Ibn Sa'd ٥/ ١٦٠; Tabaqat Khalifa, entry ٢٠٧٨; al-Ma'arif ٢٣٥; al-Ma'rifa wa-l-Tarikh ١/ ٣٦٨; Akhbar al-Qudat ١/ ١٢٠; al-Jarh wa-l-Ta'dil, section ١, volume ٤٧٢; Tarikh Ibn Asakir ٨/ ٢٦٦; Tahdhib al-Kamal p. ٦٢٧; Tarikh al-Islam ٤/ ١٦; Tadhhib al-Tahdhib ٢/ ١٠٤; al-Muhabbar of Ibn Habib ٣٥٦; Tahdhib al-Tahdhib ٥/ ١٩; Khulasat Tadhhib al-Tahdhib ١٧٩, ١٥٠; Shadharat al-Dhahab ١/ ١١٢; Tahdhib Ibn Asakir ٧, ٧٢; Nasab Quraysh ٢٧٣; Mashahir Ulama' al-Amsar ٦٧; al-Tarikh al-Kabir of al-Bukhari ٤/ ٤٣٥; Akhbar al-Qudat of Waki' ١/ ١٢٠; al-Kashif ٢/ ٣٩; Siyar A'lam al-Nubala' ٤/ ١٧٤; Jami' al-Tahsil ٢٤٥; Tabaqat al-Huffaz ٢٥.