Home > Refutations and answers to accusations > If Allah knows our choices, are we truly responsible?
Divine knowledge, the decree and human responsibility raise 3 linked questions.
The Quran attributes to the human being a will and places it under the divine will (76:29-30). The objection is to know how this dependence can be reconciled with responsibility.
Contents:
Updated on 15 November 2026 at 12:17 AM
📖 1 min readSaying that Allah knows what I will do does not describe, on its own, the way I act. The debate on the decree goes further than divine knowledge alone: it also bears on the relation between God's will and human action.
Quran 76:29 calls whoever wills to take a path to his Lord. The following verse places that will under Allah's. Quran 2:286 also ties the judgment to what the person has earned and to her capacities.
In religious practice, intention, capacity and constraint count. Belief in the decree is therefore not a general excuse for the acts one chooses. The schools of theology have proposed several analyses of the relation between human decision and divine creation.
The texts address calls and obligations to persons able to act. They take account of capacity and constraint.