Islamic Fiqh > Foods and drinks > Sea creatures: fish, crustaceans and seafood
What is lawful from the sea: the jumhur's rule, the divergences on crustaceans and predators, with the manuals' evidence.
What lives in the sea is lawful without slaughter according to the Malikis, the Shafi'is and the Hanbalis, on the verse “lawful to you is the game of the sea and its food” (al-Ma'ida 96) and the hadith “its water is purifying, its dead is lawful”: the Malikis extend the rule to all marine species. Among the Shafi'is, the soundest view gives the lawfulness of everything (crab, turtle, frog), while the Hanafis restrict lawfulness to fish alone (al-A'raf 157). The fish floating dead in the water divides: forbidden among the Hanafis, lawful for the majority. Non-floating fish and the fish cast up by the sea are lawful for all.
Table of Contents :
Updated on 07 October 2026 at 6:42 PM
The sea follows a regime of its own: what lives in it requires no slaughter, and its lawfulness in principle is established by the Quran. The schools draw from it different consequences according to the species, and the encyclopedia of the four schools draws the complete map: fish, sea animals, species of the 2 worlds, each with its ruling.
The scholars agree on the lawfulness of non-floating fish: Abu Bakr al-Jassas says so without divergence among the Muslims, along with the locust. All kinds of fish enter the agreement, including the eel and the lamprey cited by the Hanafis. No slaughter is required: what lives only in water is permitted without slaughter, without known divergence, on the hadith: '2 dead animals and 2 bloods have been made lawful to us: the 2 dead animals are fish and the locust; the 2 bloods, the liver and the spleen' (Ibn Majah 3314; Ahmad 5723).
Its water is purifying, its dead animal is lawful.
hadith of the sea, reported by al-Muwatta, Ahmad, Abu Dawud, at-Tirmidhi, an-Nasa'i and Ibn Majah
The story of the amber illustrates the rule: Abu Ubayda and his companions, 300 men out on an expedition and reduced to sucking dates, found on the shore a dead animal called anbar; Abu Ubayda declared: it is a dead animal, then: no, we are the envoys of the Messenger of Allah in the way of Allah, compelled: eat. They stayed on it a month, until they grew fat, collected the oil of its eye and carried off strips of flesh; back in Medina they reported the matter to the Prophet, who said: 'it is a provision Allah has brought out for you; do you still have some to give us?' and he ate of it (Muslim 1395).
The school of Malik draws the verse to its generality: 'the game of the sea is permitted to you' (sura al-Ma'ida 96), and the hadith of the sea. Every maritime catch is eaten, its dog and its pig, what resembles a land animal and what does not: the texts are general, nothing requires slaughter, the animal is lawful alive and dead (al-Istidhkar, at-Tamhid, al-Ma'una). Ibn Hubayra sums up the school: with Malik everything is eaten, dead of its own death or of a cause, slaughtered by a Muslim or a Magian, floating or not; he only paused over the sea pig.
The Shafi'is divide the animals that water does not kill into 2 groups. The first: what lives in the water and outside it dies like a slaughtered animal, all fish: lawful without slaughter and without divergence, whatever the cause of death, visible pressure, the shock of a stone, withdrawal from the water, the fisherman's blow, or natural death; floating or not, all is lawful without divergence.
The second group: what does not have the known figure of fish, crab, turtle, frog and others; the school holds 3 views on it. The strongest among the companions of the school: all is lawful; this is the text of al-Shafi'i in al-Umm, the Mukhtasar of al-Muzani and the Ikhtilaf of the Iraqis, for the name of fish covers all these animals, and Ibn Abbas read the verse thus: 'its game, what is hunted; its food, what it casts up'. The second view forbids all: this is the position of Abu Hanifa.
The third compares: what whose land equivalent is eaten, like the sea cow and the sea sheep, is eaten; what whose equivalent is not eaten, sea pig and sea dog, is not eaten; what has no equivalent is eaten. The strongest requires no slaughter for any of these animals.
The Shafi'is isolate the animals that live in the water and on land. Water birds, duck and goose, are lawful but their dead animal is not eaten: they require slaughter, without divergence.
The frog and the crab are forbidden on the correct view of the school, retained by the majority, because of the report of Said ibn al-Musayyab from Abd ar-Rahman ibn Uthman: a physician mentioned before the Messenger of Allah a remedy into which the frog entered; the Messenger of Allah forbade killing the frog (Abu Dawud 5269; Ahmad 15795); if its flesh were lawful, the prohibition on killing it would not hold. A weak view nevertheless permits it.
The venomous animals, sea snake and others, whose venom leads to death or illness, are forbidden without divergence. The crocodile is forbidden on the correct known view; the turtle is forbidden on the stronger of the 2 views (al-Hawi, al-Muhadhdhab, al-Majmu').
The Hanafi school reads the verse of foods the other way: all that is in the sea is forbidden, except fish in all its kinds; and even fish that floats dead is excluded. The crab, the turtle, the frog, the sea pig, the sea dog and the sea man are neither eaten nor sold, on the verse: 'he forbids them the foul things' (sura al-A'raf 157): what is not fish is foul in their reading (Bada'i as-Sana'i, al-Hidaya).
The Hanbalis follow the generality of the verse: Abu Bakr said of all that is in the sea: 'Allah has slaughtered it for you', and the hadith reported from Ata and from Amr ibn Dinar: 'Allah has slaughtered for the son of Adam all that is in the sea'. Only the frog is excluded, because the Prophet forbade killing it.
On the crocodile, Ibn Qudama reports from Ahmad what indicates the prohibition; al-Awza'i saw no harm in eating it for whoever wished; Ibn Hamid forbade it, it and the kawsaj, for they devour men; and Ibrahim an-Nakha'i reported disgust at predatory sea animals as at land ones, on the prohibition of 'every beast with fangs'.
The Hanbali detail is rich: what lives on land requires slaughter, water bird, turtle, sea dog; but what has no blood, like the crab, is eaten without slaughter: Ahmad answered that there is no need to slaughter it, for slaughter serves to evacuate the blood and to cleanse the flesh by ridding it of it. On the sea dog, part of the school excluded it with the sea pig, the sea snake and the sea scorpion, in the name of the land counterpart; the skin of the sea dog remains used: al-Hasan ibn Ali rode a saddle of that skin, and Malik, al-Shafi'i and al-Layth allowed it (al-Mughni).
The fish that dies in the water without visible cause then floats divides: the Hanafis forbid it, the majority permits it on the verse and the words of Abu Bakr, Umar and Ibn Abbas reported by al-Bukhari; the page of the divergences over foods gives its detail. Non-floating fish and the one the sea casts up on the shore are lawful for all.
The table of the sea is read in 2 circles: the majority extends the permission of the verse to all that comes from the sea, with the Shafi'i and Hanbali exceptions on the frog and the predators; the Hanafi school holds to fish alone. Each follows his school, the divergence being ancient and documented on both sides.
Al-Mughni by Ibn Qudama · Hanbali school
Question 1746; he said: 'that whose dwelling is the sea while it lives on land is not eaten, whether it dies on land or at sea'. All that lives on land among the beasts of the sea does not become lawful without slaughter, like the water bird, the turtle and the sea dog, except what has no blood, like the crab, which is permitted without slaughter.
Ahmad was asked: the crab, is there any harm? He said: no harm. He was told: does one slaughter it? He said: no; for the purpose of slaughter is to extract the blood and to cleanse the meat by ridding it of it; what has no blood does not need to be slaughtered.
Al-Mughni by Ibn Qudama · Hanbali school
Abu Ubayda and his companions found on the seashore a dead animal called the amber, they ate from it a month until they grew fat and anointed themselves with it; when they returned to the Prophet, peace and blessings upon him, they informed him and he said: it is a provision Allah has brought out for you; do you have any of its flesh to regale us with? Reported by al-Bukhari and Muslim.
This is the floating-fish divergence: the Hanafis forbid it, based on the carrion verse and a weak hadith (Abu Dawud 3815); the majority permits it on the generality of al-Ma'ida 96 and the words of Abu Bakr, Umar and Ibn Abbas reported by al-Bukhari. Fish killed by a visible cause and those cast ashore are lawful for all.
The schools split: forbidden to the Hanafis, who limit the sea to fish; forbidden in the retained Shafi'i view; lawful to the Malikis with the whole sea; lawful to the Hanbalis, and Ahmad specified it is not slaughtered, having no blood, slaughter serving to drain it.
The Shafi'is forbid it in the stronger of two views; the Malikis permit it with all that lives in the sea; the Hanbalis permit it when slaughtered, Ahmad seeing no harm in a slaughtered turtle; the Hanafis exclude it as anything that is not fish.
Yes: this is the amber of Jabir's account. 300 companions reduced to sucking dates found a dead one on the shore, ate from it a month until they grew fat and carried provisions; the Prophet said: 'It is a provision Allah has brought out for you', and he ate from it (Muslim 1395).
The Malikis permit it with the whole sea; the Shafi'is permit it in the strongest view; the Hanafis exclude it; the Hanbalis eat its meat after slaughter for part of the school, others excluding it by the land counterpart. Its skin however is used: al-Hasan ibn Ali rode on a sea-dog skin saddle, approved by Malik, al-Shafi'i and al-Layth.
The report of Said ibn al-Musayyab excludes it: a physician mentioned before the Prophet a remedy containing the frog, and the Prophet forbade killing it (Abu Dawud 5269; Ahmad 15795). The Shafi'is and Hanbalis derive the prohibition of its flesh; yet Ibn Abd al-Barr counted the frog among what Malik permitted.
Editorial method and corpus: see our editorial transparency page.