Islamic Fiqh > Foods and drinks > Eating the forbidden out of necessity (darura)
The necessity rule: what the Quran permits when life is at stake, its limits (the necessary, not the surplus) and its modern application.
Whoever fears dying of hunger or thirst may eat of the forbidden, carrion, blood, pork or what was slaughtered for other than Allah, to the measure that wards off death: this is the scholars' unanimity, based on the verse “no sin is upon him” (al-Baqara 173). The permission stops at satiation: the surplus is no longer covered by compulsion, and Malik reports that one must eat one's fill, make provision, then return the rest if one finds means of living. Darura is assessed case by case and ceases as soon as the danger recedes. It imposes a duty toward others: not letting die the one whom one can feed (Ibn Abd al-Barr).
Table of Contents :
Updated on 07 October 2026 at 6:42 PM
The rule of necessity (darura) runs through the whole fiqh of foods: the absolute prohibition yields before announced death. The verse recurs in the Quran: 'whoever is compelled, without being rebellious or transgressing, no sin weighs upon him' (sura al-Baqara 173). The encyclopedia of the four schools fixes its extent, its measures and its limits.
The people of knowledge agree: every food prohibition becomes permitted to the one who fears for his life destruction by hunger or thirst, to the measure of what wards off death: carrion, blood, pork, what was slaughtered for other than Allah. Ibn Qudama records the agreement in both directions: forbidden by choice, permitted under compulsion, on the verse of al-Baqara. An-Nawawi formulates it for the whole: the community agrees that the compelled person, if he finds nothing pure, eats of impurities, carrion, blood, pork and what resembles them; and all agree that if he finds pure food belonging to him, he must eat it (al-Majmu').
Ibn Hazm records the agreement in close terms: carrion, blood and pork are lawful for the one who fears perishing of hunger having not eaten the day before, without being a brigand or a forbidden traveler; the measure that repels death is unanimous, and the divergence bears only on the surplus and on the wine of the compelled (Maratib al-Ijma'). Ibn Hubayra adds the limit: the agreement holds so long as it is not a matter of human flesh and the compelled person finds nothing else.
On the quantity, the schools separate into 2 blocs. Abu Hanifa, al-Shafi'i and their companions limit: the compelled person eats of the carrion only the measure that holds the breath; Abdullah ibn al-Hasan spoke of the measure that cuts hunger. Their proof: the permission is born of the fear of dying; once the fear is removed, the necessity falls and the permission with it.
Malik, in his Muwatta, teaches what was retained as most correct: the compelled person eats to satiation and makes provision of the carrion; if he afterwards finds means to do without it, he throws away what remains. Al-Hasan said likewise: 'if he is compelled to the carrion, he makes it his food'. The elevated hadith goes in this direction: the Prophet was asked when the carrion became lawful; he answered: 'so long as you take neither breakfast nor dinner' alongside (reported by Ahmad).
Ahmad holds 2 narrations, and the more apparent of his school refuses satiation; Abu Bakr chose the permission, on the report of Jabir ibn Samra: a man settled on the Harra and his family wanted to preserve the she-camel that had died among them; the Prophet asked whether he had means to do without it; no; 'then eat it' (Abu Dawud 3816, chain judged good).
Ibn Qudama arbitrates: if the necessity lasts, as for the Bedouin who questioned the Prophet, satiation is permitted, for limiting oneself to the breath would bring the necessity back at once and weaken the body to the point of losing it; if the necessity is called to cease, one keeps to the measure of the breath while hoping for the lawful (al-Mughni).
Two positions. The first makes it a duty: Masruq said of the one who is compelled to the carrion, does not eat of it and dies, that he enters Hell; it is one of the 2 views of the Shafi'is and the choice of Ibn Hamid, on the verses: 'do not throw yourselves into destruction' (sura al-Baqara 195) and 'do not kill yourselves' (sura an-Nisa 29): abstaining from eating when one can in this state is throwing oneself into loss.
The second refuses: the permission is a dispensation, and dispensations are not imposed. It relies on Abdullah ibn Hudhafa, companion of the Prophet: the tyrant of the Romans shut him in 3 days with wine cut with water and roast pork; he touched none of it until his head reeled and his death was feared; once out, he said: 'Allah had made it lawful for me, for I was compelled; but I would not give them the joy of belittling the religion of Islam'. The one who can repel the impurity while keeping his faith intact commits no fault (al-Mughni).
Ibn Abd al-Barr draws from it a social consequence: it is not permitted to the one who knows the state of a man in danger of death to let him perish while he holds means to hold his breath. If he is alone, the duty falls on him alone; if they are several, it is a collective duty for that day and night, which falls as soon as one of them takes it on. The compelled person likewise has no right to abstain from what keeps him alive to the point of dying of it: the saying of Masruq holds for him and for the others (al-Istidhkar).
The compelled person who eats the property of another, harvests or food, eats it lawfully; the schools differ over compensation. Some impose guaranteeing what saved the life; the majority imposes no guarantee on one who was compelled. A practical case settled by the encyclopedia: the compelled person finds a carrion and the food of an absent man; Malik, most Shafi'is and part of the Hanafis: he eats of the food of the other with the charge of guaranteeing; Ahmad, the rest of the Hanafis and Shafi'is: he eats of the carrion (al-Ifsah).
Human flesh remains: Ibn Hubayra records that Malik in the retained view and Ahmad refuse it even to the compelled person, while the companions of Abu Hanifa and al-Shafi'i permit it to the measure of the necessity. As for wine, Ibn Hazm notes it: the scholars have differed over the wine of the compelled person, without agreement.
We made 7 expeditions with the Messenger of Allah eating the locust.
reported by Abdullah ibn Abi Awfa; al-Bukhari and Abu Dawud
The locust is lawful outside necessity by unanimity of the people of knowledge, notes Ibn Qudama, on the hadith: '2 dead animals and 2 bloods have been made lawful to us: the 2 dead animals are fish and the locust'. The majority, al-Shafi'i, the people of hadith, the people of opinion and Ibn al-Mundhari, do not distinguish there the cause of death; Malik and Said ibn al-Musayyab require a cause, and Muhammad ibn Abd al-Hakam, a Maliki, follows the general hadith. Fish follows the same regime, which prepares the page of sea animals.
The permission holds in town and in travel: the verse is absolute, and the necessity of famine strikes the town too; the motive is the preservation of life, which dominates the avoidance of impurities, and this motive is the same everywhere (al-Mughni). Ahmad defines it without fixed delay: the one who fears for his life, whether he fears dying of hunger, or no longer being able to walk and being cut off from the caravan, or no longer being able to ride. The necessity is assessed case by case and ceases with the danger.
The page holds in 3 lines: the measure that repels death is lawful by unanimity; the surplus beyond satiation is forbidden by unanimity; between the 2, satiation and provisions, the schools differ and the position of Malik is reported as the most correct. The duty to feed the one who is dying falls on whoever can.
Al-Mughni by Ibn Qudama · Hanbali school
Chapter: if he is compelled, must he eat of the dead animal? There are 2 positions. The first: he must; this is the saying of Masruq and one of the 2 views of the companions of al-Shafi'i, and the choice of Ibn Hamid, for Allah said: do not throw yourselves with your own hands into destruction, and abstaining from eating when one can in this state is throwing oneself into it.
The second: it is not incumbent on him. Abdullah ibn Hudhafa, a companion of the Messenger of Allah, was shut in by the tyrant of the Romans in a room where he placed with him wine mixed with water and roast pork for 3 days; he neither ate nor drank until his death was feared, then he came out and said: Allah had made it lawful for me, I was compelled; but I would not give them, against the religion of Islam, anything to rejoice at.
Al-Hawi al-Kabir by al-Mawardi · Shafi'i school
Al-Shafi'i said: it is not permitted to eat of an oil in which a mouse has died. Al-Mawardi said: its basis is what al-Shafi'i reported from Ibn Abbas from Maymuna: a mouse fell into clarified butter and died in it; the Messenger of Allah was asked about it, and he said: throw it away, it and what surrounds it, and eat the rest.
Al-Mughni by Ibn Qudama · Hanbali school
Chapter: eating the locust is permitted by consensus of the people of knowledge. Abdullah ibn Abi Awfa said: we made 7 expeditions with the Messenger of Allah eating the locust; reported by al-Bukhari and Abu Dawud. There is no difference between its dying with a cause or without a cause according to the generality of the people of knowledge, among them al-Shafi'i, the people of hadith, the people of opinion and Ibn al-Mundhir.
Our proof: the general scope of his saying, peace and blessings upon him: 2 dead animals and 2 bloods have been made lawful to us; and he did not detail.
The measure that repels death is unanimous; beyond it, two camps: Abu Hanifa and al-Shafi'i limit it to what sustains life, Malik allows eating to satiety and storing provision, then discarding the rest once lawful food is found; Ahmad holds both narrations and Ibn Qudama distinguishes lasting from short-lived necessity.
With Malik, yes: the compelled eats to satiety and takes provision, then discards what remains once he finds sustenance. Such is the sense of the hadith: carrion is lawful 'as long as you take no breakfast nor supper' beside it, and of the camel of al-Harra: 'Do you have sufficiency? No. Then eat it' (Abu Dawud 3816, good chain).
Two positions: one makes eating a duty, with Masruq saying that whoever abstains and dies enters the Fire, based on the verses on destruction; the other excuses it, following Abdullah ibn Hudhafa who refused pork and wine for three days at the risk of his life. For witnesses however, the duty to feed the dying is certain (Ibn Abd al-Barr).
Some require guaranteeing what saved his life; the majority impose no compensation on the compelled. Precise case: finding both carrion and an absent owner's food, Malik and most Shafi'is have him eat the other's food under guarantee, Ahmad and the others have him eat the carrion (al-Ifsah).
Not by agreement. Ibn Hazm records it: scholars agree on the measure repelling death for carrion, blood and pork, but they differed on the compelled person's wine, without consensus. The common rule remains the measure repelling death, and wine is not part of the basic permission.
That is the limit set by Ibn Hubayra: the agreement on necessity holds as long as it is not human flesh. Malik in the retained view and Ahmad refuse it even to the compelled; the companions of Abu Hanifa and al-Shafi'i permit it to the measure of necessity, when nothing else exists.
Editorial method and corpus: see our editorial transparency page.