Organ donation and transplant

Islamic Fiqh > Funerals > Organ donation and transplant

Donating an organ during life or after death: the academies' conditions, the prohibition of selling and the consent register.

Organ donation is admitted by the contemporary Sunni academies as a means of saving a life: « whoever saves it is as if he had saved the whole of mankind » (sura al-Ma'ida 32). Resolution no. 26 (1/4) of the Fiqh Academy of the OIC (Jeddah, 1988) permits the graft during life if the organ regenerates or if the removal inflicts no great harm upon the donor, and after death with the authorization of the deceased, of his heirs or of the competent authority, death being certain; sale is forbidden in every form. Ibn Baz and Ibn Uthaymin on the contrary forbade removal from the dead: the question is not settled by consensus.

Updated on 07 October 2026 at 6:42 PM

Donating a kidney during one's lifetime, accepting the removal of organs after death, registering on a donor registry: so many questions that contemporary medicine has posed to fiqh. The Sunni academies have answered them with dated and argued resolutions; leading scholars have held the opposite view. This page presents both, with their exact conditions.

The principle: saving a life

The Quranic foundation of the debate is the verse: « therefore We prescribed to the children of Israel that whoever kills a soul, without reason of another soul or of a corruption on earth, is as if he had killed the whole of mankind; and whoever saves it is as if he had saved the whole of mankind » (sura al-Ma'ida 32). The graft of an organ, when it saves a life or repairs a body, enters this aim of preservation; it must still respect the body of the donor, living or dead, which Islam declares inviolable.

Resolution 26 (1/4) of the Fiqh Academy of the OIC

The International Islamic Fiqh Academy, body of the Organization of Islamic Cooperation, adopted at its 4th session, in Jeddah from February 6 to 11, 1988, resolution no. 26 (1/4) on the use by man of the organs of the body of another, living or dead. It states 5 rules:

  • the transfer of an organ from one place to another of the same body is permitted, if the expected benefit preponderantly outweighs the harm;
  • the transfer of an organ from one person to another is permitted if the organ regenerates by itself, like blood or skin;
  • the removal of an organ from a living donor is permitted on condition that it does not inflict great harm upon the donor, and by reason of the necessity of preserving the life of the sick person or of a preponderant benefit;
  • the transfer of an organ from a dead person to a living one who needs it is permitted, with the authorization of the donor before his death, or of his heirs after his death, or of the competent authority, and on condition that death be established with certainty;
  • the sale of organs is forbidden in all its forms: the organs of the human body cannot be subjected to commerce.

Decision 99 of Hay'at Kibar al-Ulama

In Saudi Arabia, the council of Hay'at Kibar al-Ulama had opened the way as early as its decision no. 99, dated 6/11/1402 of the hegira (1982), on the transfer of an organ or a part of an organ from one person to another: the council ruled unanimously upon its permission, accompanied by safeguards, among them the capacity and free consent of the living donor, the absence of serious harm to him, the authorization tied to the deceased for posthumous removal, and the exclusion of any price: the organ is neither sold nor exchanged. This founding text served as the basis for the Saudi regulations of organ donation.

Donation during life: the detailed conditions

From the 2 texts flows a common regime for the living donor. The organ must be either regenerating, like blood or skin, or removable without great harm, like a kidney or a fragment of liver in a healthy person; an organ whose removal kills or heavily disables, like the heart, is excluded by the condition of the absence of great harm. The donor must be legally capable, and his consent free: no one can be constrained, neither by the family nor by anyone.

The expected benefit for the recipient must be real and preponderant, which physicians alone can establish: the OIC resolution conditions its permissions upon the medical appraisal of the probable success. These conditions are not formalities: capacity and freedom protect the donor against pressure, the absence of great harm protects his body, the preponderant benefit protects the recipient against a useless risk.

These conditions are not formalities: each protects a weak party. Capacity and freedom protect the donor against pressure; the absence of great harm protects his body; the preponderant benefit protects the recipient against a useless risk.

Why a vital organ is not removed from a living person

The rule of harm suffices to trace the limit. The regenerating organs, blood and skin, renew themselves after the donation: the harm is temporary. The double organs, like the kidney, or partly regenerable ones, like a fragment of liver in a healthy person, leave the donor living normally: the harm is mastered. A single and vital organ, like the heart, kills the one deprived of it: its removal from a living donor is excluded by the very condition of the permission. This is what radically distinguishes donation during life from posthumous donation: the first cannot cost the donor's life, the second intervenes when life has already ceased.

What fiqh says to families at the time of death

When a relative dies in a situation of possible donation, the chain of authorizations fixes the order of the decision-makers: first the will of the deceased expressed during his lifetime, by registry or donor card; failing that, his heirs; failing that, the competent authority. The family that refuses does not transgress the religious law: the deceased who authorized nothing keeps the inviolability of his body, and the view of Ibn Baz and Ibn Uthaymin supports this refusal.

The family that accepts follows the resolutions of the academies and generally honors the will of the dead. In both cases, the body is then returned to his own for the Muslim funerals, washing, shroud, prayer and burial, which lose nothing of their integrity.

Removal after death: consent and certainty of death

For removal from a deceased, resolution 26 (1/4) requires 2 guarantees: an authorization, given by the deceased during his lifetime, failing that by his heirs after his death, failing that by the competent authority when the public interest requires it; and a certain death, established according to recognized medical criteria. The national consent registries and donor cards are the modern shaping of this anticipated authorization: they document the will of the deceased and spare the families a decision in urgency.

The dignity of the body remains the constant limit: the Prophet said: « breaking the bone of the dead is like breaking it for a living person » (Abu Dawud 3207). The academies hold that the necessity of saving a life, or of preserving one preponderantly, justifies the minimal reaching of the body of the deceased, in respect of what he has authorized.

Embryos, source of graft: resolution 56 (7/6) of 1990

The Fiqh Academy of the OIC completed the framework at its 6th session, in Jeddah in March 1990, with resolution no. 56 (7/6) on the use of embryos as a source of graft. Its central rule: it is not permitted to provoke an abortion with the aim of using the organs of the fetus for a graft; use is limited to spontaneous unprovoked abortion and to abortion authorized for a legal reason. If the fetus is viable, no operation is practiced upon it, except if its life depends upon it, with the agreement of its parents and under medical supervision.

The sale of organs, trafficking and constraint

The firmest prohibition of the device is commerce: resolution 26 (1/4) proscribes the sale of organs in all its forms, and the logic of the academies admits neither trafficking, nor graft tourism, nor pressure upon vulnerable donors. The permission of donation rests in effect upon 2 pillars which disappear as soon as a price enters in: the gratuity of the act and the absence of constraint. A purchased donation is no longer a donation, and a donor constrained by need is no longer free. The national regulations that frame donation in the medical milieu protect precisely these 2 pillars.

The opposite view: Ibn Baz and Ibn Uthaymin

The question is not closed by consensus. Ibn Baz and Ibn Uthaymin forbade the removal of organs from the dead, in their published fatwas, out of veneration for the body of the deceased and refusal to reach it for the benefit of another; their position rests upon the inviolable character of the dead, marked by the hadith of the broken bone. The partisans of permission answer with the verse of the saving of life and with the consent of the deceased. The 2 views are documented and argued: the Muslim who hesitates may follow the view of the majority of the academies or that of the 2 scholars, without his good faith being called into question.

Practical note on organ donation and graft

The Muslim decides during his lifetime: registering or not on the national donor registry is a licit choice in view of the resolutions cited; informing one's family avoids hesitations at the critical moment. The one who chooses not to give incurs no blame: donation is a generosity, not an obligation. In case of doubt over a specific case, the question belongs to a medical counsel and an individual fatwa.

Frequently asked questions

Is organ donation permitted in Islam?

Yes according to the contemporary Sunni academies, under conditions: resolution 26 (1/4) of the Fiqh Academy of the OIC (1988) and decision 99 of Hay'at Kibar al-Ulama (1402H) admit the graft if the living donor suffers no great harm and consents freely, or if the deceased authorized the removal during his lifetime or via his heirs, death being certain.

May an organ be removed from a living donor?

Yes in 2 cases according to resolution 26 (1/4): the organ that regenerates by itself, like blood or skin, and the organ whose removal inflicts no great harm upon the donor, like a kidney, on condition of free consent and of a preponderant benefit for the recipient. A vital organ like the heart is excluded.

May organs be removed from a dead person without his agreement?

No: resolution 26 (1/4) requires the authorization of the donor before his death, or of his heirs after his death, or of the competent authority. It also requires a certain death, medically established. The consent registries and donor cards serve to document this anticipated authorization.

May an organ be sold or paid for?

No: resolution 26 (1/4) forbids the sale of organs in all its forms. The permission of donation rests upon gratuity and free consent; any trafficking or graft tourism falls under this prohibition.

May one abort to remove fetal organs?

No: resolution 56 (7/6) of the Fiqh Academy of the OIC (1990) forbids provoking an abortion in order to use the organs of the fetus; use is limited to spontaneous abortion and to abortion authorized for a legal reason. A viable fetus is operated upon only if its life depends upon it, with the agreement of the parents.

Are all the scholars agreed upon organ donation?

No: Ibn Baz and Ibn Uthaymin forbade removal from the dead, out of veneration for the body of the deceased, supported by the hadith: « breaking the bone of the dead is like breaking it for a living person » (Abu Dawud 3207). The academies hold the permission; the divergence exists and is documented on both sides.

Sources and references

Editorial method and corpus: see our editorial transparency page.

Other pages of this pillar

Explore other sections

بسم الله الرحمن الرحيم Sat 10 Jumada al-Thani
السبت 10 جمادى الآخرة
أحدب متزايد Waxing Gibbous Day 11.5 / 29.5
Illumination 88%
Full moon in 3 days
سبحان الله Glory be to Allah

إِنَّ ٱللَّهَ وَمَلَٰٓئِكَتَهُۥ يُصَلُّونَ عَلَى ٱلنَّبِىِّ ۚ يَٰٓأَيُّهَا ٱلَّذِينَ ءَامَنُوا۟ صَلُّوا۟ عَلَيْهِ وَسَلِّمُوا۟ تَسْلِيمًا

God and His angels shower their blessings on the Prophet. O believers, you should also send your blessings on him, and salute him with a worthy greeting.

Al-Ahzab 33:56

Blessings on the Prophet ﷺ