Entangled successions: when the heir dies before division

Islamic Fiqh > Inheritance and wasiya > Entangled successions: when the heir dies before division

When heirs die together or nearly: the condition of life at the death, the drowned and the buried, the unknown order of deaths, the divergence of the schools on mutual inheritance and the fate of the missing person and the captive.

To inherit requires being alive at the death of the deceased: dead together, 2 heirs transmit nothing to each other, agreement. The order unknown, the great number gives the property of each dead to his living heirs, on the practice of Zayd ibn Thabit with the slain of Yamama, of Amwas and of al-Harra (al-Mabsut 30/27-29); the Hanbalis transmit, on the letter of Umar, the old property only. A certain order of forgotten identity suspends the doubtful (Ibn Abidin 6/798-799). The missing person is not declared dead: 90 years, the term of the judge or 4 years according to the cases; only the living at the division inherit (al-Mughni 6/263-264).

Updated on 07 October 2026 at 6:42 PM

Potential heirs dying in the same accident, an uncertain order of deaths, a missing relative: the successions intertwine, and the fiqh applies to it a single rule, the certain life of the heir at the death of the deceased, declined by the schools into precise cases, from the slain of Yamama to the missing person of today.

The first condition: to be alive at the death of the deceased

Inheritance requires the life of the heir after the death of the one from whom he inherits: doubt founds no certain right. Of 2 heirs dead without known order, each is presumed not to have survived the other, as the child born dead neither opens nor receives inheritance; the certain right of the living heirs does not yield before a doubtful right, and the original of life is not reversed without proof.

Dead together in one single circumstance: no inheritance between them

When a group drowns, is crushed under a wall, perishes in a fire or falls in battle, and they died in one same known instant, none inherits from the other: agreement of the scholars, recorded among others by al-Mawardi; the estate of each returns to his own living heirs, for none was alive at the death of the other.

The order of the deaths unknown: each estate to its living heirs

When it is not known who died first, Hanafis and Malikis, with the great number of the ancients, separate cleanly: the property of each dead goes to the living heirs of each, without mutual transmission. Al-Sarkhasi records the agreement of the first ones: Abu Bakr, Umar and Zayd ibn Thabit judged thus of the drowned and the burned; Zayd divided the estates of the slain of Yamama, sent by Abu Bakr, of the dead of the plague of Amwas, sent by Umar, and of the slain of al-Harra; Ali judged likewise of the slain of al-Jamal and Siffin; Umar ibn Abd al-Aziz followed, and with them the great number of the jurists (al-Mabsut 30/27-29).

Example of the manuals: 2 brothers drowned, each leaving 90 dinars, a daughter, a mother and an uncle; the estate of each is divided between his living daughter, mother and uncle, without either inheriting from the other. Another example: a husband, his wife and their 3 sons buried under a collapse, order unknown, the husband leaving another wife, the wife a son from another bed; to the living wife the quarter of the husband's property, the rest to the residuary heirs; the wife's property to her son; and the sixth of each son's property to their mother's brother, the rest to the residuary heirs.

The traces of the ancients support it: the slain of Yamama, of Siffin and of al-Harra transmitted nothing between them, and their living agnates inherited (reported by Sa'id in his Sunan); Umm Kulthum, daughter of Ali, and her son Zayd ibn Amr died together on the road, their 2 cries crossing, without anyone knowing who preceded: she inherited not from him, nor he from her.

The combined computations of the manuals: 72 shares and 36 shares

On the view of mutual transmission, the manuals combine the estates. A brother and a sister drowned, both leaving spouses, their mother and their uncle: the brother's estate is settled between his wife, his mother and his sister, then what returns to the sister between her husband, her mother and her brother, and the question rises to a base of 72 shares; the view of separation settles each estate alone, without combination (al-Mughni 6/255-256).

Another example: 3 germane brothers drowned leaving their mother or agnates; supposing the death of one first, the mother takes the sixth of his estate and the rest to the 2 others; then what each of the 2 received is settled between his mother and his agnates, and the question rises to 36 shares, where the mother totals 16 shares and the agnates the rest (al-Mughni 6/255-256). On the view of separation, each brother leaves his own estate to his living heirs.

The Hanbalis: inheritance of the old property, not of the transmitted property

The Hanbali school, on the letter of Umar at the time of the plague of Amwas, "transmit to them the inheritance of one another", makes each dead inherit from his co-deceased, but of the old property only (tilad), what he possessed at his death, not of the transmitted property (tarif), what he would have received from the other: without this limit, the circle would turn, one inheriting from the other who inherits from him. Ahmad says: I go toward the view of Umar.

The letter of Umar is reported by al-Shu'bi in an interrupted way: weak hadith (Sa'id ibn Mansur, Sunan 1/35, no 232). And the hadith where the Prophet, questioned about people crushed by a house, would have said that they inherit from one another in fact stops at Iyas al-Muzani: authentic as a saying of the companion (Abd al-Razzaq 19159; Ibn Abi Shayba 31994). A narration of Ali and of Ibn Mas'ud transmitted mutual inheritance, except what each held from the other; no jurist followed it. Abu Thawr, Shurayh and Basrans suspended: to each his certain due, the doubtful waits.

One death known in advance, an identity forgotten

If it is certain that one of the 2 preceded the other, without knowing which, the Hanafis (one view) and the Malikis treat them as simultaneous dead: the property of each to his living heirs. The late Hanafi texts give to each his certain due and suspend the doubtful: 2 drowned brothers each leaving a daughter, each daughter takes the half of her father, and the rest waits until the order is revealed or the heirs compromise (Ibn Abidin 6/798-799).

The Shafi'is likewise suspend, from the estate of each, the share of the one who was with him, until the evidence or the agreement of the heirs (al-Hawi al-Kabir 8/87); the Hanbalis apply to this case the mutual inheritance of the old property, as to the unknown order.

When the heirs confront each other: the oaths

If the heirs of each dead claim that theirs died last, without proof, they mutually swear to push away the opposing claim: the proof lies with the claimant, the oath with the denier; the inheritance does not pass, for lack of certain life after the death. Example: a woman and her son dead without known order; the husband claims she died first, her brother the opposite: oaths on both sides, the son's property goes to his father, the woman's to the husband and the brother, half each.

If the heirs date the death of one and doubt of the other, the one doubted of inherits from the dated dead: the origin is life, which is not reversed by doubt (al-Mughni 6/256-257).

The missing person and the captive: the waiting inheritance

The missing person (mafqud) whose news was cut off on a journey of healthy appearance, trade, quest for knowledge or captivity among an enemy who does not kill his captives, is not declared dead: the 4 schools wait. The Hanafi principle sums it up: alive for his own property, which is not divided; dead for the property of others, of which his share is reserved like that of the child to be born.

The delays diverge: 90 full years since his birth according to the Hanbali view and Ibn al-Majishun; for the great number of the schools, the term beyond which life is impossible, assessed by the judge; the Hanafi narrations detail: when none of his like survives any longer, or 120 years since his birth according to al-Hasan from Abu Hanifa, or 100 years according to another narration; the Malikis require in addition the formal judgment of the judge at the end of the life expectancy. The one among the heirs of the missing who dies before the declaration takes nothing from him: only those living on the day his property is divided inherit from the missing person (al-Mughni 6/263-264).

If he reappears after the division, he takes back his property found in kind, and the value of what was consumed.

The suspended shares when an heir is missing

When a deceased leaves a missing heir, the manuals give to each his certain due and suspend the doubtful: he who would fall entirely if the missing lives receives nothing; he who would see his share vary according to his life or death receives the lesser of the 2 rights; he who does not vary receives his whole share.

3 examples from the manuals: a missing husband with 2 consanguine sisters and an uncle present; if the husband lives, the sisters have 4 shares out of 7 and the uncle falls; if he is dead, the sisters have the 2 thirds and the rest goes to the uncle: the sisters are given 4 out of 7, the lesser of the 2 rights, and the rest waits.

A grandfather, a germane brother and a missing consanguine brother: for the grandfather the missing is presumed living and he takes the third; for the germane he is presumed dead and he takes the half; the remaining sixth awaits clarification. A missing son with a daughter and a husband present: the husband has the quarter in every case.

If the disappearance bears traces of apparent destruction, shipwreck where some die and others not, disappearance of the home, deadly desert, melee of battle: Hanafis and Shafi'is treat the missing as the traveler; the Hanbalis wait 4 years, then divide his property after settlement of the zakat of the past years, his wife completes her waiting period and may remarry, by agreement of the Companions; the Malikis distinguish: lost between 2 Muslim lines, he is declared dead at the end of the battle; lost facing the disbelievers, his property waits a year; missing in a time of plague, he is inherited at the passing of the epidemic, death being preponderant there.

Practical note on intertwined successions

After a common catastrophe: date each death if possible; the order established, the survivor transmits to his heirs; the order unknown, each property returns to the living heirs of each dead, according to the view of the great number; the doubtful shares are suspended, and the missing person waits for his legal term. The combined computations belong to the tables of faraid.

The evidence among the classical schools

Al-Sarkhasi said: Abu Bakr, Umar and Zayd ibn Thabit agree on the drowned and the burned when it is not known who died first: none inherits from the other, and the estate of each returns to his living heirs. On this, Zayd judged the slain of Yamama when Abu Bakr sent him to divide their estates, the dead of the plague of Amwas when Umar sent him, and the slain of al-Harra; Ali judged likewise of the slain of al-Jamal and Siffin; Umar ibn Abd al-Aziz said it, and the great number of the jurists follows him (al-Mabsut 30/27-29).

The slain of Yamama, of Siffin and of al-Harra transmitted nothing between them, and their living agnates inherited (Sa'id, in his Sunan). Umm Kulthum, daughter of Ali, died with her son Zayd ibn Amr at simultaneous cries on the road: it was not known who died first, and they did not inherit from each other. For the condition of inheritance is the life of the heir after the death of the deceased; doubt founds no right; the original is the absence of transmission; and inheriting each from the other would be a certain error.

The letter of Umar: the typhus struck the land of Sham in the year of Amwas, and people died by whole houses; they wrote to Umar, who ordered: transmit to them the inheritance of one another (al-Shu'bi, in an interrupted way: weak hadith, Sa'id ibn Mansur, Sunan 1/35, no 232). Ahmad says: I go toward the view of Umar. And the hadith of the people crushed by a house, that they inherit from one another, stops at Iyas al-Muzani: authentic as a saying of the companion (Abd al-Razzaq 19159; Ibn Abi Shayba 31994).

Ibn Abidin exposes the states of the intertwined dead and the rule of the Hanafi texts: when it is known that one preceded without knowing which, to each his certain due, and the doubtful is suspended until the evidence or the transaction of the heirs (commentary on ad-Durr al-Mukhtar 6/798-799). The missing person, as for him, is declared dead only at the end of the wait; only the living on the day of the division inherit from him (al-Mughni 6/263-264).

Frequently asked questions

Do a father and son killed in the same accident inherit from each other?

If the order is established, the survivor inherits then passes on to his heirs. Otherwise, for the majority of schools there is no transmission: each estate goes to its living heirs; the Hanbalis transmit inheritance of the old property only, not of what came from the other.

A husband and wife drowned together: who inherits?

Neither takes from the other: dead in the same instant, neither was alive at the other's death; each estate returns to its own living heirs, the deceased spouse no longer among them.

Can the youngest be presumed to have survived?

No: the law presumes no order; only a proven order passes the estate. In doubt, each estate stays with the deceased's living heirs, the certain prevailing over the doubtful.

How long must a missing relative be awaited?

Safe-looking journey: 90 full years since birth (Hanbalis, Ibn al-Majishun), or a term assessed by the judge (majority), with narrations of 100 or 120 years; disappearance amid apparent destruction: 4 years among Hanbalis, 1 year against the disbelievers among Malikis.

An heir of the missing person dies before the death declaration: does he inherit?

No: only the heirs living on the day the estate is divided inherit the missing person; whoever dies before, even by a day, is as one dead in his lifetime.

The missing person returns after his estate was divided: what does he recover?

Whatever is found in kind, and the value of what was consumed: his right never lapsed, the declaration bearing only on appearances.

Heirs contradict each other on the order of deaths: how is it settled?

By proof, failing that by oaths: each side swears the other's claim false, on 'proof lies with the claimant, the oath with the denier', and the estate does not pass; example: the woman and her son, the husband against the brother.

Sources and references

Editorial method and corpus: see our editorial transparency page.

Related glossary terms

Other pages of this pillar

Explore other sections

بسم الله الرحمن الرحيم Sat 10 Jumada al-Thani
السبت 10 جمادى الآخرة
أحدب متزايد Waxing Gibbous Day 12 / 29.5
Illumination 92%
Full moon in 3 days
لا حول ولا قوة إلا بالله There is no power nor strength except with Allah

إِنَّ ٱللَّهَ وَمَلَٰٓئِكَتَهُۥ يُصَلُّونَ عَلَى ٱلنَّبِىِّ ۚ يَٰٓأَيُّهَا ٱلَّذِينَ ءَامَنُوا۟ صَلُّوا۟ عَلَيْهِ وَسَلِّمُوا۟ تَسْلِيمًا

God and His angels shower their blessings on the Prophet. O believers, you should also send your blessings on him, and salute him with a worthy greeting.

Al-Ahzab 33:56

Blessings on the Prophet ﷺ